p16 and Ki-67 immunohistochemical staining reduces inter- and intra-observer variability in the grading of cervical squamous intraepithelial lesions of South African women

  • Christa Solomon National Health Laboratory Services
  • Melanie Louw National Health Laboratory Services
  • M C Van Aardt University of Pretoria
  • Greta Dreyer University of Pretoria
Keywords: CIN, HPV, LLETZ, observer variability, South Africa

Abstract

Background: Cervical carcinoma was the second leading malignancy in South African women (following breast carcinoma) in 2010. This study aimed to correlate histopathological criteria and immunohistochemical stains in terms of the grading of cervical intraepithelial precursor lesions and evaluate intra- and inter-observer variability with only histology and with additional immunohistochemical stains. Methods: Archival tissue from large-loop excision of the transformation zone (LLETZ) was graded on two separate occasions by an independent observer in terms of lesional severity. The section with the highest grade precursor lesion was selected and submitted for immunohistochemical stains that included p16 and Ki-67. These stains were also evaluated on two separate occasions by an independent observer. Results: This study showed kappa values of 0.47 and 0.46 respectively for the separate histological evaluations of the observer and the original pathology report. The kappa value for the two evaluations of the observer was 0.57. Thus inter- and intraobserver variability is fair with the use of routinely stained histological slides. The two Ki-67 assessments had a kappa value of 0.85 and the p16 had a value of 0.80. Intra-observer agreement was markedly higher when using immunohistochemistry. Conclusion: Although in most cases of precursor lesions of the cervix the grading can be made on routinely stained sections, intra- and inter-observer variability remains high. Immunohistochemical markers reduce this variability and aid in deciding in which group to place ambiguous lesions. (Full text available online at www.medpharm.tandfonline.com/ojgo) South Afr J Gynaecol Oncol 2017; DOI: 10.1080/20742835.2017.1370841

Author Biographies

Christa Solomon, National Health Laboratory Services
National Health Laboratory Services (Tshwane Academic Division) Department of Anatomical Pathology University of Pretoria Pretoria
Melanie Louw, National Health Laboratory Services
National Health Laboratory Services (Tshwane Academic Division) Department of Anatomical Pathology University of Pretoria Pretoria
M C Van Aardt, University of Pretoria
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology University of Pretoria Pretoria
Greta Dreyer, University of Pretoria
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology University of Pretoria Pretoria
Published
2017-12-04
Section
Research Articles